Billions on Showtime, 3.05: Flaw in the Death Star

In case you haven’t noticed, I tend to watch stuff with the eyes of one who looks for dark and light and all the gradations in between. Light for the fun and entertaining, dark for the real and true. This episode, “Flaw in the Death Star”, balanced the two quite nicely, never spending too much time in either extreme and provided a fair and balanced view of this world we’ve come to know as Billions

We find Bobby’s flight plans cut short by The Halls telling him they can’t find anything on the doctor who supplied the juice to spike Ice Juice. Like folks pre-Pasteur who believed in spontaneous generation and not in invisible beings like bacteria and such, Bobby has made a fatal error in not collecting the slide that provided the bugs with which he manipulated the murder of Ice Juice. He’s left some key evidence out in the wild, and in this episode, he finds out if he’s to pay for the oversight of slighting those invisible germs.

Over at Chez Rhoades, the difficulty of knowledge management issues is not to be underestimated. Chuck is up in the middle of the night and wakes up Wendy to say: I know, but, since that knowledge was obtained behind your back, you’re under no obligation to acknowledge that you know that I know. I have to do something with my knowledge, even if you tell me not to, because I can’t not.

The level of honesty between these two? What a crazy thing to behold in dramatic television. This is the way real couples talk when they want to stay a couple, laying it all out, dirty secret by dirty secret. Never such a thing as too much honesty in my book. But, then again, maybe things are more delicate for the Rhoades. Theirs is a fate still to be determined.

In short, Chuck knows, from looking at Wendy’s comprehensive session notes in S1, that Bobby told Wendy he could have allowed Donnie some experimental treatment for his pancreatic cancer, an opportunity to live longer. Instead, Bobby convinced Donnie’s doctor to not give him the info about the experimental protocol.

Chuck doesn’t know the name of the doctor, but he gets everything else he needs from Donnie’s widow.

Meanwhile, Bobby seems to have developed some level of clairvoyance or something, an ability to envision alternate paths to events. No doubt, he always had that ability, but in this episode we see it, ala those close-up flashback microscopic thoughts some of us may remember seeing when House was working out the details of a rare disease. We see in flashback what he thinks may have happened and then the other thing that could have happened. He wouldn’t be the superhero he is if he didn’t have this skill, the ability to concurrently see loyalty juxtaposed with betrayal, trusting a person and simultaneously distrusting. You have to wonder what that kind of skill does to a mind. Like, you want to believe the best in people and act accordingly. But what if you see the worst in people at the exact same time? A problem soul-shattering enough to be tackled by the Marvel universe if it weren’t being tackled right here by Damian and this show via Bobby.

In the halls of truth and justice and the American way, Connerty has an a-ha moment sparked by girlfriend McKayla sharing that Boyd is losing his initials on the company jet.

One day your initials are on a jet, next day you’re in jail.

And next day you’re out.

Bryan teases his revelation with Kate, who guesses right away without cue: Why is Boyd not in jail?

Axe has sent Taylor in his stead where Oscar had promised Axe Capital a dog and pony show on investable start-ups. In a series of vibrant jazzy call and response, Taylor calls the show for what it is: a test for Axe Cap to be able to identify Oscar’s bottom tranche. (ie the losers every investor packages with the winners in order to sell them…see The Big Short for details) Oscar retorts: it’s about diversifying! Taylor counters: diversification in apps for millennials? Pa-lease. Test or not, Oscar gets Taylor to stay and see more.

Geek love is the best love, don’t let anyone ever tell you different. There’s something really special about bonding over shared knowledge of exhaust ports and playing a hand or three of the most intricate world-building games. The back and forth about the flaw in the Death Star is the most Weiner-esque I’ve heard this show be. And that’s because the language delineated two characters from the rest of the world around them.

The battle of Dollar Bill vs Spyros deserves a headline. Dollar Bill wants to short Mendham Pharmaceutical whose risk has been mitigated by a bag of bills….and “research.”

Spryos says no. Dollar Bill loses his mind.

Wendy drags the dueling boys into her office like some middle school vice-principal. She attempts couples therapy while Dollar Bill takes manspreading to another level. He laments wasting three seconds on the PC speak.

You’re not an earner.

Wendy’s exhausted with the kids. She wonders if she can do the same for Chuck and Axe.

If you were a couple, I’d say break up. But we are more than married here.

Dollar Bill apologizes.

Then things get ugly very quickly when Dollar Bill determines that apologizing was just not his style. He’s got nothing to lose apparently, Keyser Fucking Soze that he is. So why not ram Spyros where it hurts the most.

There will be fall-out from the car stuff, I’m sure. It’s a freakin Porsche afterall. This act of violence may be a symptom of Bill going the way that Wags did last season, falling off the wagon sanity-wise just because his one true hero and mentor has fallen. Let’s just say his thermal exhaust port could use some ventilation.

Kinda know how he feels, maybe? I mean, around here we go a bit batty when Damian’s not on screen. But, no, that’s different, because we’re sane, generally, and not fictional characters, prone to bouts of cinematic violence.

Something tells me such a display of violence isn’t just a sight gag though. The show is showing us men, and the varied craziness they can exhibit under various forms of duress, both external and self-inflicted. How they can blow up even the pretty things.  Ultimately none of those exhibits of real male violence are as cool or as fun as the movies would have us believe. And yet we can have fun watching them. Nice how that happens (and disconcerting at the same time, no?).

Dollar Bill wants to vent about Spyros with his buddy Axe. Axe reminds him the walls have eyes and ears.  A comical wonderfully performed scene of “Strip or Retire”, ie Roman  nude wrestling, players showing that they have skin in the game…literally. Bill strips down to his flannel boxers to reveal his wirelessness.

Bobby eventually tells Bill to cut it out. And he also puts Spyros in his place. If anyone’s going to do some threatening, it’s going to be Bobby.

In gathering sympathy from Wags, Wendy takes us back to when Bobby and Chuck first met. Chuck was in private practice, and they were friends! They saw themselves in each other, acknowledging each other as both the smartest men in the room. Twinsies. She mourns over the loss of that relationship. Could it be she misses when Chuck wasn’t on the side of the law? Axe was always Axe, but Chuck used to be a private attorney raking in the dough, probably clearing as many bad guys as he did good guys. She prefers him in that position, rather than his current role as the arbiter of all that is lawful.

Simpler times.

But now is now, and Wendy’s choices are narrow.

What’s my choice, succumb to a case of the vapors? It’s either that or soldier on.

Kate goes to Chuck with the Boyd stuff and asks and/or plants the thought that Boyd could’ve been released thanks to active cooperation, ie. snitching on some of his own people, thereby sealing Boyd’s records in the interest of “witness safety and investigative integrity.”

While she came up with this play, she’s up to play longer, fully expecting Connerty to appeal.

Chuck goes to Boyd to confirm things are still copasetic and to get the names he needs to maintain the cover that Boyd was released because he’s an informant. Boyd is all: What good is a get out of jail free card if one can’t yacht to Antibes on a whim?

Over on the left coast, Taylor is getting an earful from a start-up for voice recognition sign-ins. Taylor identifies the flaw in the guy’s plan: he doesn’t own the voice recognition technology that he wants to retool. That is his thermal exhaust port, referring to the title of the episode, a decades long in-joke on the plot hole in Star Wars circa 1977. Darth Vader’s ship had a flaw, a tiny hole that was an Achilles heel for the massive orb. Luke Skywalker dropped explosives right in and blew up the Death Star, saving the day for all of humanity and many sequels and prequels to follow. Oscar and Taylor agree it wasn’t a plot hole at all.

What material could withstand the heat of that mammoth sphere.

I noted (via tweet) last week that Taylor had a reaction to Oscar sitting at the table at the Ethiopian place and talking exclusively to Axe without even looking at them. And I thought then, wait, do these two have some history. Maybe some dating history and he just doesn’t recognize Taylor now? Because when he finally looked over he reacted in sort of a confusion, that could’ve been due to her gender nonconformity or perhaps a vague note of recognition? Anyway, since no one else seemed to have seen it, I thought it was just me and didn’t mention it in my review. But, darn it if first instincts aren’t everything: there was something to those looks afterall. Note in my tweet the vain plea for confirmation from the actors, as if they’d tell me anything, pros that they are. Alas, we amateurs gotta amateur.

The dialogue in this episode sounded positively David Chase-ian and Matthew Weiner-ific. Rapid-fire back and forth, so much unsaid that it keeps you guessing, but you get it because the language is tight and the subtext of it is delivered almost subliminally. Like Oscar and Taylor chatting about the flaw in the Death Star. Fine, it would help if the viewer was in on the story, and most viewers of the Star Wars generation are. But it doesn’t really matter because the point is that the two characters are totally in on it. They come from similar worlds where exchanging sci-fi geek speak is as effortless as breathing. That was what Matthew Weiner did with dialogue, he put people in the same mind space, where they didn’t have to say every word or express everything explicitly to convey the notion that they were in sync. They got the same references, they spoke the same language, because they lived in the same world. And, often the references referred to something in that character’s past or something about a relationship which had already been established in the show. Likewise, in the rapporte between Oscar and Taylor, we know from his first appearance that Oscar can spout Middle Earth logic (but not sports ball stuff), and Taylor is someone who knows sci-fi and fantasy and poker and maybe baseball, but not necessarily in a sports player sort of way. When they refer to Star Wars with each other there is no need for suspension of disbelief because it’s believable.

The fact that Bobby Axelrod knows EVERYTHING, is, however, not absolutely believable, unless he is indeed a superhero. He can have a Blade Runner laden conversation with Orrin, identify Middle Earth speak from Oscar, even if he doesn’t speak it, knows his hands of poker, knows about cars and sports. And didn’t he talk about ancient world battles once? Like a history geek or someone who flipped thru wikipedia one day memorizing it all. And when Bobby is around his buddy Bill, he’s a family guy. They both share a love of The Game. But, the “I’m going to poke you now” scene showed some of the familial dynamic between Bobby and Bill, when they asked how each other was doing. Bill, we can imagine, feels very at home (in both his homes), lazing on the couch and watching the game with this kids, taking his boys to pitch practice, all the Dad stuff you see dads do. So we can imagine Bobby and Bill dad-ing it up together, sharing beers over Usual Suspects and Inglorious Bastards.

Billions pulls a lot of references from a world external to itself. Perhaps this is because it’s a relatively young show and the relationships that would lead to internal references aren’t absolutely carved out yet. Seems that in world creation, you come with a bucket of references, and, as an alternative to throwing all of them into the world and seeing where they land, you do some categorizing first, sketch out whose mouths to put those references. Not to say that a sports geek cannot also be a sci-fi geek, but, it’s awfully rare, isn’t it, to see that overlap of knowledge in one person? Unless that person is a super hero, which Bobby Axelrod very well may be.

In multiple sources, the powers that be and those that work for them have hinted that it’s not just Chuck and Axe set to traverse difficult moral terrain in this season, other characters will be balls-deep as well. Methinks Taylor is definitely one of the characters to watch as they negotiate choppy waters. Oscar may be geek friendly, but he also may be setting up Taylor to get to Axe in some nefarious way.

Finally, the readiness with which Bobby picks up the phone to call Wendy speaks to the anxiety he feels that he may really fall this time. We’ve seen him call her before at all hours of the night, but not so immediately, not so urgently. He needs her not to talk him through a delicate trade like usual. This night, he needs her for the basic survivalist need of helping him figure out what the hell to do if he ends up in jail.

Donnie’s doctor holds the key and he’s flooded with ideas on where to use it. He likes neither option: Axe the sole criminal and Chuck the lawman obsessed with a sole criminal instead of doing his duty for the good of all. Both are the same beast to the good doctor. Axe has put the squeeze on the doctor’s research funding and lab and he offers a reward for the incriminating slide. Chuck goes a wee bit smarter route. He says all he needs is the physical evidence that is the slide, and the doctor can be as far removed from the evidence so as not touch him one bit. The good doctor wants his lab and he wants his family and his birds. He does not want to be touched, so he chooses the lesser evil: Chuck. Leaving Axe fucked.

Is the good doctor the flaw in the death star? Or is it Taylor and/or Dollar Bill on the Axelrod side, and Wendy in the Rhoades corner? Keeping it all in is dangerous, but so, apparently, is letting off that steam.

10 thoughts on “Billions on Showtime, 3.05: Flaw in the Death Star”

  1. Have you considered review for the trailers? The next episode seems to have Spyros bring info that pulls Axe out of chair. So intrigued.. Any speculations? Is it chuck planting a devious info to Axe through Spyros? There’s history too..

    1. Hm, interesting read on the preview! Here’s what I see:

      Spyros meets with Chuck. He’s been wronged….the animals he works with destroyed his car, so he’s got beef now. So I’m not sure he’s still on Axe’s side. Then he’s shown taunting Bobby, Orrin, and Wags with “the spotlight turns to Mr and Mrs Rhoades”…two possibilities here:

      1) the taunt as ironic, meaning, Spyros knows he works for the bad guys, he wants to stay, but they have no respect for him, so he’s going to betray them; this is the possibility I’m leaning towards, given their expressions. They’re not happy.


      2) the taunt is not ironic, meaning, Spyros still wants to be in Axe’s good graces. He works in cahoots with Connerty to reveal the Rhoades role. He knows about Chuck’s plan, and knows that Wendy benefitted.


      3) as you say, Chuck gives something delicate to Spyros in the hopes that it will choke Axe. But, given their history, Chuck has no respect for Spyros either, so I don’t know why they’d start working together now.

      Whatever the case, the point of intersection is Wendy, who is primed to get screwed from all directions. I don’t believe firmly in any of these speculations. Nothing is obvious. Which makes this show so darn watchable.:)

  2. Jania, The ability to develop a mountain out of mole.. That’s what Billions does to fans.. lets hope the writers surprise us..

  3. You definitely called it, partner — the geek love! And it was lovely. I loved it that they were turned on with a Star Wars convo followed by a round of Netrunner. I so loved that they loved each other’s brains before they loved each other’s bodies. But, honestly, I did not see it coming. You did — BRAVO!

    I completely agree about the transparency in Chuck and Wendy’s relationship at the moment. And I think the “couples therapy” she had with Dollar Bill and Ari Spyros could be a rehearsal for what is coming: Can you imagine Wendy holding a joint session with Axe and Chuck? That would be EPIC to say the least!

    My favorite part of this episode was Axe being challenged: A man that he cannot simply buy off with money — a new concept for the super hero! 😀 I loved it when he finally had his read: “I’m fucked.” 😀

    The show feels more and more like an ensemble act this season — Kelly AuCoin and Stephen Kunken totally killed it! OMG the apology, the handshake, and I completely agree it seems Dollar Bill is losing it like Wags did last season. He does his “research” and he is uncertain but he cannot get his way — it is taking its toll on Dollar Bill.

    1. Thanks lady!

      Since Wendy herself mentioned that she should do the same couples therapy for Axe and Chuck makes me think it won’t happen, but, it would be certainly a delight if it did! Those three in a room together (which, I think, has NEVER happened as far as I can recall) would be a scene for the ages….a stage-worthy scene that could take up an entire episode and knock the entire surrounding world into the background. Come to think of it, didn’t Damian mention that some such epic-ness, eg one scene in particular, was going to make the fans very happy? If he was hinting at this very thing, then, hell yes, it would make this fan VERY happy.

      That said, I’m happy that this season is more an ensemble act. Spyros has been a revelation this season. So funny! 😀 And Bill flashing his print-outs and saying “I got research!” was hilarious.

      1. Axe, Chuck and Wendy were in a scene together in Season 1 at Big Apple Circus where Axe helped little Kevin to meet Mark Teixeria. But it was not a scene where the three of them had a real conversation. Seeing them, in your words, the A-team, together would be a true treat! And, yes, Damian mentioned a scene in the season finale which includes Axe and Chuck that he thought would put a smile on everyone’s faces.

        I’m also loving the show being an ensemble act — I think Damian also mentioned that in the podcast with Willie Geist. The show has some of the best actors, and makes good use of the talent. It is wonderful they all have an opportunity to shine on screen!

  4. I love that Oscar and Taylor connected the way that they did. I have a question. After Oscar and Taylor made love and spent the night together, I didn’t quite hear what Oscar said to Taylor as she was leaving in the morning. It was something like: “I hope you were not disappointed” or some other phrase with the word “disappointed.” Can you tell me what was said and and the possible meaning.

    1. Oscar: “I know you were initially unimpressed. I’m pleased you’ve come around.”
      Taylor: “Pleased as well to make this investment.”

      What it means: Taylor was not immediately attracted to or impressed by Oscar, nor even happy to be in San Francisco at all. They thought it was all a waste of time. They eventually came around. To both the investments that Oscar showcased for Taylor and, of course, in other more personal ways. 🙂

  5. 1. Axe leaving the slide with the good doctor was so uncharacteristic of the character. Death Star, indeed.

    2. Axe is conniving, manipulating, and a criminal, but Chuck is just an ahole.

    3. Why are there two mini Halls now? I must have missed his departure of Terry Kinney.

    4. It was Antonie Philips van Leeuwenhoek, a fellow Dutchman, whom “discovered” bacteria. He called them animalcules. He lived from the early 1600s to the early 1700s. Pasteur lived from the early to the late 1800s.

    5. Didn’t Chuck switch to public practice because his father had political aspirations for him?

    6. Kate just destroyed her career with the forgery.

    7. Dollar Bill makes me laugh. Spryos makes me cringe-laugh.

    8. Dollar Bill would have stolen “The Post”, not “The Daily News”.

    Great recap. I always love to read other’s interpretations. Thank you.

    1. Yes, I was going to say Leeuwenhoek at first, since I remembered him from biology classes as the one who first “saw” bacteria via his work in microscopy. I also confused him with Redi, whose experiment with meat under glass is one of the most memorable experiments in bio. Redi’s experiment made the first step towards disproving spontaneous regeneration in that he showed that something in the air made meat decay. So your fellow Dutchman indeed saw bacteria, and the chances that those animalcules were responsible for Redi’s decaying meat were strong, but it wasn’t until Pasteur that the theory was fully laid to rest. It takes a village!

      No matter though, cuz it seems it’s not bacteria on that slide at all, but some mysterious toxin that evaporates after 18 hrs. And what places that slide goes. Makes a former biologist cringe. 🙂

      Thanks for reading!

Join the conversation!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.